I once asked Claude to generate a SQL query with the temperature cranked up to 1.2 because I thought “creativity” would help. What I got back was technically creative SQL that would have deleted my entire database if I’d actually run it. Creative? Absolutely. Useful? Not even remotely.
Then I tried the exact same prompt with temperature set to 0.0 and got a perfect query with zero creativity and all correctness. Temperature settings fundamentally change what you get back, but most people never touch them at all.
Table of contents
Open Table of contents
What Temperature Actually Does
Temperature controls the randomness of the AI’s word choices at every step of generation.
Low temperature (0.0-0.3) picks the most statistically likely word every single time, giving you predictable and accurate responses that rarely vary.
Medium temperature (0.5-0.8) makes the AI consider less-likely word options beyond just the top choice, resulting in output that’s creative but still coherent and grounded.
High temperature (1.0 and above) encourages the AI to take real risks with word selection, producing output that’s genuinely weird. Sometimes it’s brilliantly creative, but more often it’s complete nonsense.
Here’s the restaurant analogy: Temperature 0.0 is ordering the exact same meal every single time you visit. Temperature 0.7 is trying the daily special because it sounds interesting. Temperature 1.5 is ordering a random item from the menu with your eyes closed and hoping for the best.
When to Use 0.0-0.3 (Deterministic)
Use low temperature when you need accuracy over creativity and there’s really only one correct answer.
Code generation needs this because you want the function to actually work, not to use “creative” syntax that breaks everything. Data extraction has one correct answer in the source material and you don’t want the AI inventing new data. Technical documentation must be correct and clear, not creative and confusing. Math and calculations need right answers with minimal hallucination, not creative interpretations of arithmetic.
When to Use 0.5-0.8 (Balanced)
Use medium temperature for natural writing and conversation where you want personality without losing coherence.
Blog posts and articles need this range to sound natural and engaging instead of robotic and boring. Emails to real humans should use conversational phrasing while staying coherent and professional. Explanations of complex topics benefit from creative analogies and varied phrasing while staying grounded in accuracy. Summarization captures the key points while maintaining flexibility in how those points are expressed.
When to Use 0.9-1.5 (Creative)
Use high temperature when you explicitly want unexpected ideas and need to break out of predictable patterns.
Brainstorming sessions thrive on wild ideas where even if 90% are terrible, that one brilliant insight makes it worthwhile. Creative fiction writing wants unexpected plot twists and character decisions that low temperature would never generate. Naming products or features benefits from seeing unusual options instead of just “the most statistically likely name.” Breaking through writer’s block sometimes requires controlled chaos to shake loose new directions.
Examples
Here’s the same exact prompt “Write the first sentence of an article about coffee” at three different temperature settings:
Temperature 0.0 output: “Coffee is one of the most popular beverages in the world, consumed by millions of people daily.” This is accurate and boring, basically Wikipedia.
Temperature 0.7 output: “I’ve never understood people who don’t drink coffee - how do they even function before 9am?” This is conversational, engaging, and has actual personality.
Temperature 1.5 output: “Coffee whispers secrets to the morning, dancing through neurons like a caffeinated symphony of consciousness.” This is genuinely creative and weird, maybe poetry, definitely not normal.
Problems
High temperature leads directly to hallucinations: At temperature 1.5, the AI will confidently state completely made-up “facts” as absolute truth. It picks unlikely word tokens that form convincing-sounding nonsense that seems authoritative but is totally wrong. For any factual questions, use low temperature.
Low temperature sounds extremely robotic: At temperature 0.0, you get only the statistically most likely words, which means common clichéd phrases with zero personality or natural variation. For marketing copy or social media where personality matters, you want something in the 0.6-0.8 range instead.
Sweet Spot Guide
0.0: SQL, code, math, data extraction 0.2: Technical docs, APIs, structured data 0.5: Emails, reports, explanations 0.7: Blog posts, articles, conversation 0.9: Marketing, social media, brainstorming 1.2+: Fiction, poetry, experimental, ideas
Test with your use cases. Adjust.
Temperature vs Top-P
Temperature scales the probability distribution of all possible tokens, where higher values introduce more randomness across the entire range of options.
Top-P (also called nucleus sampling) cuts off unlikely tokens entirely from consideration, where lower values mean only the most likely options are even available for selection.
Most people should just use temperature and ignore top-p entirely. If you’re getting weird results even at high temperature, try lowering top_p to 0.9 to remove the really unlikely options. Personally, I set top_p to 1.0 and only adjust temperature based on my needs.
Common Mistakes
Never changing temperature from the default: You use the same setting for absolutely everything, which means your code generation gets hallucinations from too-high temperature while your creative writing sounds robotic from too-low temperature.
Setting it too high for factual content: You get confident, authoritative-sounding lies because the AI is picking unlikely words that form plausible but completely wrong statements.
Setting it too low for creative marketing: Your copy sounds like it was written by reading the instruction manual because it’s just stringing together the most statistically common phrases.
Not experimenting with the full range: You never actually try the same prompt at 0.0, then 0.7, then 1.2 to see what temperature does to your specific use case.
My Settings
Here’s what I actually use in practice for different tasks:
Code generation: 0.0 because I want it to work, not to be creative Blog articles: 0.7 for natural conversational flow with personality Brainstorming sessions: 1.0 to get genuinely unexpected ideas Debugging code: 0.1 to stick very close to known patterns Social media posts: 0.8 for personality and engagement Test data generation: 0.0 for consistency and correctness Professional emails: 0.6 for natural but not too casual Technical documentation: 0.3 for clarity with minimal creativity
I change temperature settings way more often than I change my actual prompt text.
Bottom Line
Temperature is not some minor technical setting you can safely ignore. It fundamentally changes the nature of the responses you get back from the AI.
Low temperature gives you accuracy at the cost of being boring and robotic. Medium temperature provides the best balance and is useful for most real-world tasks. High temperature unlocks creativity but also introduces chaos and potential nonsense.
Most developers completely ignore this setting, get mediocre results that don’t quite work for their use case, and then blame the AI for being bad. But if you actually change temperature based on your specific task, your results improve immediately and dramatically.
That slider everyone ignores because they don’t understand it? Actually use it. It matters way more than you think.